MLB: what top Polymarket traders hold
MLB games and futures. These are the MLB markets on Polymarket in which at least five of the top traders we track hold a position, with the side most of them hold (the consensus), what share of them hold it and the market's own price for that side.
A consensus is a head count of who holds what, not a probability, and following it did not pay on average in our backtests — see how it works.
- Live consensus markets
- 14
- Recently settled, consensus right
- 10 of 12
- Prices as of
- Oct 25, 07:19 UTC
Live MLB consensus markets (14)
- Will the Milwaukee Brewers win the 2026 World Series?Traders hold No 40%8 of 21 tradersMarket price 16¢$102K heldagainst the market price
- Will the Tampa Bay Rays win the 2026 World Series?Traders hold No 42%8 of 20 tradersMarket price 84¢$63K held
- Will Mark Kotsay win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%8 of 8 tradersMarket price 0.1¢$0 heldagainst the market price
- Will Derek Shelton win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%7 of 7 tradersMarket price 0.1¢$0 heldagainst the market price
- Will Kurt Suzuki win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%7 of 7 tradersMarket price 0.1¢$0 heldagainst the market price
- Will Chad Tracy win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%7 of 7 tradersMarket price 0.1¢$0 heldagainst the market price
- Will Aaron Boone win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%7 of 7 tradersMarket price 0.1¢$0 heldagainst the market price
- Will Joe Espada win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%7 of 7 tradersMarket price 0.1¢$0 heldagainst the market price
- Will Matt Quatraro win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%7 of 7 tradersMarket price 0.1¢$0 heldagainst the market price
- Will John Schneider win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%7 of 7 tradersMarket price 0.1¢$0 heldagainst the market price
- Will Dan Wilson win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%7 of 7 tradersMarket price 0.1¢$0 heldagainst the market price
- Will Craig Albernaz win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%6 of 6 tradersMarket price 0.2¢$1 heldagainst the market price
- Will A.J. Hinch win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold Yes 100%6 of 6 tradersMarket price 0.1¢$0 heldagainst the market price
- Will Stephen Vogt win the 2026 AL Manager of the Year?Traders hold No 20%1 of 5 tradersMarket price 100¢$185 held
Top traders in MLB
Tracked traders with 10 or more settled MLB consensus markets whose side won more often than its entry price implied, ranked by how much (on the low end of a 95% interval, so a short lucky run does not rank first). These records run optimistic: Polymarket's closed-position data rarely lists bets that went to zero.
- 1.stochi+59 ptsside won 100% of 792 · avg entry 41¢ · ROI +58%
- 2.hedgevaultmainnet1+51 ptsside won 100% of 614 · avg entry 49¢ · ROI +50%
- 3.0xAbF543512f33E2D754ada028a689610139Cccfeb-1760974401494+51 ptsside won 100% of 284 · avg entry 49¢ · ROI +50%
- 4.neymar1+57 ptsside won 100% of 43 · avg entry 43¢ · ROI +49%
- 5.0x424eb20Fcd25113e3b98f42522A54580350b263b-1774330621025+50 ptsside won 100% of 554 · avg entry 50¢ · ROI +50%
- 6.RLWG+55 ptsside won 91% of 104 · avg entry 36¢ · ROI +10%
- 7.Nooserac+49 ptsside won 100% of 407 · avg entry 51¢ · ROI +46%
- 8.0x14cA946e75D59b8B7EbE21110512f7b885d78F43-1769608890569+50 ptsside won 100% of 135 · avg entry 50¢ · ROI +52%
- 9.forsenxd+50 ptsside won 100% of 140 · avg entry 50¢ · ROI +48%
- 10.timetowander+53 ptsside won 100% of 62 · avg entry 47¢ · ROI +56%
Recently settled MLB markets
What the tracked traders held when each market settled, and how it came out. A handful of markets says little about the next one.
- Spread: Milwaukee Brewers (-1.5)Result: Tampa Bay RaysTraders held Tampa Bay Rays 46%consensus was right
- Tampa Bay Rays vs. Milwaukee Brewers: O/U 12.5Result: UnderTraders held Under 71%consensus was right
- Tampa Bay Rays vs. Milwaukee BrewersResult: Milwaukee BrewersTraders held Milwaukee Brewers 53%consensus was right
- Spread: Tampa Bay Rays (-1.5)Result: Milwaukee BrewersTraders held Milwaukee Brewers 56%consensus was right
- Spread: Tampa Bay Rays (-2.5)Result: Milwaukee BrewersTraders held Milwaukee Brewers 58%consensus was right
- Tampa Bay Rays vs. Milwaukee Brewers: O/U 9.5Result: UnderTraders held Under 70%consensus was right
- Spread: Milwaukee Brewers (-2.5)Result: Tampa Bay RaysTraders held Tampa Bay Rays 50%consensus was right
- Tampa Bay Rays vs. Milwaukee Brewers: O/U 10.5Result: UnderTraders held Under 50%consensus was right
- Tampa Bay Rays vs. Milwaukee Brewers: O/U 11.5Result: UnderTraders held Under 50%consensus was right
- Tampa Bay Rays vs. Milwaukee Brewers: O/U 8.5Result: OverTraders held Under 33%consensus was wrong
- Tampa Bay Rays vs. Milwaukee Brewers: O/U 6.5Result: OverTraders held Under 25%consensus was wrong
- Tampa Bay Rays vs. Milwaukee Brewers: O/U 5.5Result: OverTraders held Over 60%consensus was right
Holders update as the tracked traders trade, and prices refresh about once a minute. Only wallets with a position of at least 1 share count as holders; the side is the one with the most money behind it among holders with $100 or more in the market. PolyConsensus is not affiliated with Polymarket and this is not investment advice. More: all topics, the trader leaderboard, large trades.