Smart money holds the underdog side
Most tracked traders hold Mara Guth, while the market favors Carla Giambelli (52%). 10 of 18 traders hold an outcome priced under 50%.

W15 Monastir: Mara Guth vs Carla Giambelli
10 of 18 top Polymarket traders hold Mara Guth (56%) · Mara Guth at 49¢ · $41K held · ends Nov 28
⚖️
Neutral
Mara Guth
18
Mara Guth 56%
2 arb excluded
$41.3K
$4.5K
67.9¢ → 48.5¢
-29% since entry · 10 traders
Backtest pattern (not confirmed)
NeutralMara Guth at 49%
No measured edge, which here means a loss: the plain consensus (5+ holders, 60 %+, held to resolution) lost −3.0 % a trade after costs out of sample in the full-year test (n 86,296, 95 % CI −3.6 to −2.4 %).
- Consensus under 60 %Every backtest started at 60 %+ of the holders; below that nothing was measured.
- Side priced 30–50¢Full year, out of sample: 0.30–0.50 lost −4.8 % a trade (n 16,830, 95 % CI −6.6 to −3.1), worse than the plain consensus.
The rules come from our Oct 22 2026 backtest (one entry per market, held to resolution, after a 1¢ half-spread and Polymarket's taker fees). Our full-year test without hindsight (Oct 26 2026) found none of them profitable out of sample, and the plain consensus lost −3.0 % a trade. The grade describes the market; it is not a forecast, not an edge and not advice.
Smart Money Signal
10 of 18 top traders (56%)Underdog side (market favors Carla Giambelli 52%)2 arbitrage traders dimmed10 hold an outcome priced under 50%3 small positions dimmed (<$100 invested)
Outcome Probabilities
Smart Money Breakdown by Outcome
Signal Intelligence
Momentum
Flat
+0 pts consensus
Breadth
10 traders
Top 2 hold 62%
Freshness
Fresh
0h old
Flip Quality
Clean
0 consensus flips
77% of non-arb traders are on Mara Guth. Concentration is driven by the top two positions owning 62% of that side's value.
| Trader | Position | Invested | Value | PnL | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
RO robustmst | Carla Giambelliavg 26.7¢ | $9.2K | $17.7K | +$8.5K | 45% 119-143 (262) |
SL SlickRick123CTR | Mara Guthavg 72.1¢ | $7.9K | $6.4K | $-1.5K | 43% 883-1176 (2059) |
![]() WoaifacaiCTR | Mara Guthavg 56.9¢ | $5.7K | $4.9K | -$797 | 63% 311-179 (490) |
CI cigarettesCTR | Mara Guthavg 74.5¢ | $3.0K | $2.4K | -$671.2 | 54% 10176-8816 (18992) |
TH thirdt1meCTR | Mara Guthavg 72.9¢ | $3.7K | $2.4K | -$626.16 | 49% 1018-1039 (2057) |
SM smithagent | Carla Giambelliavg 43¢ | $1.7K | $2.0K | +$333.72 | 47% 1713-1956 (3669) |
![]() poshposhCTR | Mara Guthavg 73.1¢ | $1.5K | $1.2K | -$313.64 | 49% 2493-2632 (5125) |
NO NotJumpARB<$100 | Carla Giambelliavg 50¢ | $1.1K | $1.0K | -$10.5 | 49% 2668-2826 (5494) |
| └ Mara Guth leg | Mara Guthavg 50¢ | $525 | $598.5 | +$73.5 | |
| └ Carla Giambelli leg | Carla Giambelliavg 50¢ | $525 | $441 | -$84 | |
38 38791873984189 | Carla Giambelliavg 43.1¢ | $1.8K | $717.66 | -$187.09 | 48% 7882-8573 (16455) |
KE keeptheblueflagflyinghighCTR | Mara Guthavg 72.5¢ | $645.23 | $535.4 | -$109.83 | 47% 4277-4906 (9183) |
0X 0xa85B3359D5e0BDCB925F6A2B94ddfBF6d403eb0CTR | Mara Guthavg 72.3¢ | $603.7 | $484.3 | -$119.4 | 48% 793-875 (1668) |
US User7429 | Carla Giambelliavg 43¢ | $371.91 | $445.43 | +$73.52 | 51% 902-869 (1771) |
BA babybellsARB<$100 | Mara Guthavg 78¢ | $861.63 | $361.82 | -$105.97 | 41% 779-1101 (1880) |
| └ Carla Giambelli leg | Carla Giambelliavg 34¢ | $159.58 | $197.12 | +$37.54 | |
| └ Mara Guth leg | Mara Guthavg 78¢ | $221.52 | $164.71 | -$143.51 | |
KI kitopesivanCTR | Mara Guthavg 72¢ | $349.98 | $282.04 | -$67.94 | 54% 1901-1648 (3549) |
LR lryyyCTR | Mara Guthavg 70.5¢ | $259.28 | $213.44 | -$45.84 | 47% 1457-1671 (3128) |
FL Flaznorp | Carla Giambelliavg 50.3¢ | $128.82 | $138.34 | +$9.52 | 48% 8810-9648 (18458) |
0X 0xdbdd45150249e229eB4cA8aa48A30Dca21Faa5de-1757094771846CTR | Mara Guthavg 56.9¢ | $134.45 | $136.93 | +$2.48 | 44% 1413-1814 (3227) |
TO topdogbigboi<$100 | Carla Giambelliavg 35.7¢ | $54.46 | $64.11 | +$9.66 | 40% 3784-5780 (9564) |
![]() dips.<$100 | Carla Giambelliavg 43¢ | $14.19 | $17 | +$2.81 | 48% 2452-2637 (5089) |
GC GC-P<$100 | Carla Giambelliavg 53.3¢ | $8 | $7.88 | -$0.13 | 48% 1276-1371 (2647) |
Invested
$9,156.63
Value
$17.7K
PnL
+$8.5K
Record
45%
119-143 (262)
Invested
$7,899.58
Value
$6.4K
PnL
$-1.5K
Record
43%
883-1176 (2059)
WoaifacaiCTRInvested
$5,733.73
Value
$4.9K
PnL
-$797
Record
63%
311-179 (490)
Invested
$3,030.6
Value
$2.4K
PnL
-$671.2
Record
54%
10176-8816 (18992)
Invested
$3,717
Value
$2.4K
PnL
-$626.16
Record
49%
1018-1039 (2057)
Invested
$1,688.21
Value
$2.0K
PnL
+$333.72
Record
47%
1713-1956 (3669)
poshposhCTRInvested
$1,515.79
Value
$1.2K
PnL
-$313.64
Record
49%
2493-2632 (5125)
Invested
$1,050
Value
$1.0K
PnL
-$10.5
Record
49%
2668-2826 (5494)
Both legs:
Invested
$1,783.14
Value
$717.66
PnL
-$187.09
Record
48%
7882-8573 (16455)
Invested
$645.23
Value
$535.4
PnL
-$109.83
Record
47%
4277-4906 (9183)
Invested
$603.7
Value
$484.3
PnL
-$119.4
Record
48%
793-875 (1668)
Invested
$371.91
Value
$445.43
PnL
+$73.52
Record
51%
902-869 (1771)
Invested
$861.63
Value
$361.82
PnL
-$105.97
Record
41%
779-1101 (1880)
Both legs:
Invested
$349.98
Value
$282.04
PnL
-$67.94
Record
54%
1901-1648 (3549)
Invested
$259.28
Value
$213.44
PnL
-$45.84
Record
47%
1457-1671 (3128)
Invested
$128.82
Value
$138.34
PnL
+$9.52
Record
48%
8810-9648 (18458)
Invested
$134.45
Value
$136.93
PnL
+$2.48
Record
44%
1413-1814 (3227)
Invested
$54.46
Value
$64.11
PnL
+$9.66
Record
40%
3784-5780 (9564)
dips.<$100Invested
$14.19
Value
$17
PnL
+$2.81
Record
48%
2452-2637 (5089)
Invested
$8
Value
$7.88
PnL
-$0.13
Record
48%
1276-1371 (2647)
Chat
EV Calculator
Consensus % is how many tracked traders hold a side, not a win probability.
48.5¢ price + 1.0¢ spread + 1.2¢ fee (Sports 5%). Win more often than this and the bet pays.
A market order pays the taker fee and crosses the spread (assumed 1.0¢); a limit order pays no fee but may not fill. The fee category is a guess from the title.
Market Info
Traders in this Market
robustmst
Carla Giambelli — $17.7K
SlickRick123
CTRMara Guth — $6.4K

Woaifacai
CTRMara Guth — $4.9K
cigarettes
CTRMara Guth — $2.4K
thirdt1me
CTRMara Guth — $2.4K
smithagent
Carla Giambelli — $2.0K

poshposh
CTRMara Guth — $1.2K
NotJump
ARBArbitrage — excluded
38791873984189
Carla Giambelli — $717.66
keeptheblueflagflyinghigh
CTRMara Guth — $535.4